Baseball Trophies vs Medals: Which to Order for Your Team
the right award for every moment of the season.
Baseball trophies win when the award should stand on a shelf and carry a name, a title and a season; medals win when a whole roster or tournament field needs a fast, wearable handout on the field. Custom Baseball Trophies makes both from a minimum of 12, with a free mockup within 24 hours, so many leagues mix the two in one order.

Baseball trophies or medals for every award a league hands out.
Championship team
A sculpted resin or column baseball trophy for each champion player, with a larger team trophy for the dugout, where the win deserves something that stands on a shelf.
Tournament placings
Medals for first, second and third place across many teams, because a tournament director can hang them on a whole field of players in minutes on the diamond.
Full-roster participation
Participation baseball trophies for younger players who love a figure on a base, or medals for older rosters who prefer something compact to hang with past seasons.
MVP and individual honors
Baseball trophies for MVP, top pitcher, top fielder and batting title awards, where the plate needs room for the name, the honor and the season.
All-star game day
All-star medals presented on the field right after the game, paired with a ball-display award for the game MVP who keeps the actual ball.
End-of-year banquet
Baseball trophies at the banquet table for a formal presentation, while medals go home in each player's bag at the last practice before the dinner.
Custom baseball trophies styles you can order.
Column Trophies | Custom Printed in Bulk — Custom Baseball Trophies
Sculpted Resin Trophies | Custom Printed in Bulk — Custom Baseball Trophies
Acrylic & Crystal Awards | Custom Printed in Bulk — Custom Baseball Trophies
Perpetual League Trophies | Custom Printed in Bulk — Custom Baseball Trophies
Team Participation Trophies | Custom Printed in Bulk — Custom Baseball Trophies
Ball & Bat Display Awards | Custom Printed in Bulk — Custom Baseball TrophiesStop choosing one award for every moment.
Most leagues do not need to pick a side in the trophies versus medals debate. Custom Baseball Trophies lets you put championship trophies, MVP awards and a full set of tournament medals in a single order, all drawn from the same logo and colors so the season looks like one program. One mockup shows both, one approval covers both, and nothing is produced until you sign off.
- Trophies and medals in one order from 12 pieces
- Matching logo and colors across every award
- Free mockup within 24 hours, pay on approval

How baseball trophies and medals compare on what matters.
Styles
Trophies come as column, sculpted resin, acrylic and crystal, perpetual, participation and ball-display awards; medals are a single disc worn on a neck ribbon.
Personalization
Trophy plates fit a name, award title, team and season on separate lines; medal backs fit a shorter line, so long award titles favor trophies.
Quantities
Minimum of 12 for the order, and trophies and medals can be combined so a league covers champions and the full roster together.
Timing
Free mockup within 24 hours, standard turnaround about 2 weeks after approval, faster turnaround available with express shipping.
Should a baseball team order trophies or medals?
A baseball team should order trophies when the award marks a specific achievement that a player or family will display, and medals when every player on a large roster or tournament field needs the same award handed out quickly. Custom Baseball Trophies makes custom baseball trophies and medals, so the choice is about the moment, not the supplier.
Think about where the award ends up. A baseball trophy stands on a dresser or a shelf and carries a plate with the player’s name, the award title and the season. A medal hangs on a hook or in a shadow box, travels in a bat bag without breaking, and goes over a player’s head in seconds while the team lines up on the baseline.
The other question is volume. A league with a dozen individual honors and one champion team leans toward trophies. A tournament with several age groups and three placings per division leans toward medals, because the director needs to present dozens of awards in a short window between games. Many leagues land on both, which is why the custom baseball medals page sits beside the trophy styles on this site.
How do baseball trophies and medals compare side by side?
Baseball trophies offer more engraving room, more styles and more shelf presence, while medals offer faster handouts, flatter packing and easier storage for spares. The table below lines up the differences buyers ask about most when choosing between the two.
| Factor | Baseball trophies | Baseball medals |
|---|---|---|
| Display | Stands on a shelf or desk | Hangs on a hook or rack |
| Engraving room | Full plate for name, title, team and season | Shorter text on the back |
| Styles | Column, sculpted resin, acrylic and crystal, perpetual, ball-display | Disc on a neck ribbon |
| Handout speed | Best presented one at a time | Fast for a whole roster on the field |
| Transport | Needs boxes, takes space | Flat, light, packs in a bag |
| Best for | MVP, champions, coaches, banquets | Tournaments, all-stars, full rosters |
Neither option is better across the board. The table is a way to match each award on your list to the format that fits it, and the minimum of 12 applies to the order, so splitting the list between formats is normal.
When are baseball trophies the better choice?
Baseball trophies are the better choice when the award needs to say exactly what was earned and look the part years later. MVP, batting title, pitching and fielding honors, champion team awards and coach tributes all belong here, because the plate holds several lines and the trophy itself signals that the honor was a big one.
Style also matters more with trophies. Younger players often prefer sculpted resin trophies with a batter or pitcher figure. High school and adult leagues lean toward acrylic and crystal awards for a cleaner look. Column trophies scale up for a team championship, and a perpetual league trophy stays with the league and gains a new name every year.
- The award has a title longer than a few words
- The family will display it rather than store it
- The presentation happens at a banquet or ceremony
- The league wants a visible step up from what every player receives
When do baseball medals make more sense than trophies?
Baseball medals make more sense when the award goes to many players at once and has to be presented on the field. Tournament placings, all-star games and end-of-season rosters in large leagues are the classic cases. A director can hang medals on an entire team in the time it takes to call names, then clear the field for the next game.
Medals also travel well. A tournament run across several fields can keep a box of medals at each scorer’s table without worrying about broken figures. Spares are easy to hold for next season if the design avoids the year, and the flat shape suits players who collect a medal from every tournament on one rack in their room.
The trade-off is space for words. A medal back fits a shorter line, so it works best with a placing, a division or a tournament name rather than a full award title with the player’s name. If each player’s name matters, a team participation trophy may be the better fit.
Can a league order baseball trophies and medals in the same order?
Yes. Custom Baseball Trophies combines baseball trophies and medals in one order, and the minimum of 12 counts across the whole order rather than per format. A typical split puts trophies on the individual honors and the champion team, then medals on the tournament placings or the rest of the roster.
Keeping both formats in one order has practical benefits. The same logo file and team colors carry across every award, so the season looks consistent on the banquet table. One mockup shows the trophy plates and the medal artwork together, one person approves it, and the full set ships on the same timeline of about 2 weeks after approval.
- List every award the league gives, with the number of winners for each
- Mark each award as display-worthy or handout-worthy
- Assign trophies to the first group and medals to the second
- Send the list and logo through the quote form for a free mockup
What is the verdict for most baseball programs?
For most baseball programs, the verdict is trophies for the few and medals for the many. Give baseball trophies to MVPs, champions, coaches and anyone honored at a banquet, and give medals to tournament placings, all-star rosters and full-team participation when the handout happens on the field.
Youth leagues with small rosters are the exception, since young players often want a trophy with a figure no matter what the award is, and little league trophies are built for that. Fantasy and adult leagues usually skip medals and choose one perpetual trophy plus a few individual awards.
Custom Baseball Trophies returns a free mockup within 24 hours with unlimited free revisions, and you pay nothing until you approve the design. Read how it works for the steps, or plan the timing with the guide on offseason baseball trophies.
From your logo to delivered baseball trophies in four steps.
Send your artwork
Upload your logo or describe the idea and tell us the quantity you have in mind.
Get a free mockup
A designer returns a mockup of your baseball trophies with the artwork in place. Unlimited free revisions.
Approve the design
Nothing is produced until you approve the mockup, and you pay nothing before that.
Receive your order
Standard production is about two weeks after approval; faster turnaround is available with express shipping.
Custom baseball trophies for teams choosing between trophies and medals, answered.
Are baseball trophies or medals better for a tournament with many age divisions?
Baseball medals usually suit a tournament with many age divisions better than baseball trophies, because directors can present first, second and third place to whole teams quickly between games. Custom Baseball Trophies often pairs those medals with a single champion trophy per division, so the winning team still takes home something to display while every placing player receives a medal.
Do young players prefer baseball trophies over medals?
Baseball trophies with a batter, pitcher or catcher figure tend to excite young players more than medals, because the trophy is something they can set on a shelf and show to family. For tee ball and early coach-pitch divisions, participation trophies are the common choice, while older youth divisions often accept medals for tournament placings and keep trophies for season honors.
Can the same logo appear on both the baseball trophies and the medals?
Baseball trophies and medals can carry the same league or team logo in one order. Custom Baseball Trophies adapts a single logo file to the trophy plate and the medal face, keeping team colors consistent, and shows both on the free mockup within 24 hours so the person approving can confirm the whole set matches before anything is produced.
Which award holds more text, a baseball trophy plate or a medal back?
A baseball trophy plate holds more text than a medal back. A plate can fit the player's name, the award title, the team and the season on separate lines, while a medal back suits a shorter line such as a placing or event name. Leagues with long award titles generally assign those honors to trophies instead of medals.
Is it unusual to give the champion team baseball trophies and the runner-up medals?
Giving the champion team baseball trophies and the runner-up team medals is a common and well-received split. The format difference makes the championship feel distinct, while the runner-up still leaves with a quality award. Custom Baseball Trophies can match the logo and colors across both so the two sets look like part of the same tournament.
How should a league decide which awards get baseball trophies and which get medals?
Baseball trophies fit awards a family will display and that need several lines of engraving, such as MVP, champion and coach honors. Medals fit awards presented to many players at once on the field. A simple method is to list every award with its number of winners, then mark each one as display-worthy or handout-worthy before requesting the mockup.
Do baseball trophies and medals have separate minimums?
Baseball trophies and medals do not need separate minimums at Custom Baseball Trophies when they are part of the same order. The minimum of 12 applies to the order as a whole, so a league can combine a few trophies for individual honors with medals for a tournament field and still meet the minimum in one request.
Are baseball medals easier to store as spares than trophies?
Baseball medals are easier to store as spares than trophies because they are flat, light and need little space in a storage bin. Leaving the year off the design lets a league hold extra medals for next season. Spare trophies take more room, so many leagues order trophies to the exact winner count and keep extra medals instead.
Which looks better at an awards banquet, baseball trophies or medals?
Baseball trophies generally look better at an awards banquet because they stand on the presentation table and photograph well with each winner. Medals are less visible from the audience. Custom Baseball Trophies suggests trophies for honors announced at the banquet and medals handed out earlier at the last practice or final game of the season.
Can a fantasy baseball league use medals instead of baseball trophies?
Fantasy baseball leagues can use medals, but most choose baseball trophies, especially a perpetual cup that passes from champion to champion with a new plate each year. Medals work as a small keepsake for the season winner or category leaders. Custom Baseball Trophies can produce a perpetual trophy alongside individual awards in one order.
Do baseball trophies cost more to ship than medals?
Baseball trophies generally take more box space than medals, so shipping is a bigger part of the order when trophies are large or numerous. Exact charges depend on the styles, the count and the delivery address. Requesting a quote from Custom Baseball Trophies with your award list and ZIP code is the way to see the real figure for both formats.
Can baseball medals include a player's name like baseball trophies do?
Baseball medals can carry a short line of personalization, but baseball trophies are the better choice when each player's full name matters. A trophy plate gives each name its own line along with the award and season. When names are essential across a full roster, Custom Baseball Trophies often recommends participation trophies over medals.
What do all-star games usually give, baseball trophies or medals?
All-star games usually give medals to the full all-star roster and one baseball trophy to the game MVP. Medals can be presented on the field right after the final out, while the MVP award is often a ball-display trophy that holds the game ball. Custom Baseball Trophies can produce both from one design.
Which is more durable in a bat bag, a baseball trophy or a medal?
A baseball medal is more durable in a bat bag than a baseball trophy, because the flat design has no figure or column that can bend or snap. Trophies are built to stand on a shelf and travel best in their box. Players who go straight from the field to another event often find medals easier to carry home.
Should a coach award be a baseball trophy or a medal?
A coach award is almost always a baseball trophy rather than a medal. Coaches tend to display awards in an office or at home, and a trophy plate fits the coach's name, title and seasons served. Custom Baseball Trophies offers crystal, acrylic and sculpted resin styles that suit coach and volunteer honors in the same order as player awards.
How does the mockup work when an order mixes baseball trophies and medals?
An order that mixes baseball trophies and medals gets one free mockup within 24 hours showing both formats with your logo and wording. Custom Baseball Trophies offers unlimited free revisions, so you can adjust plate text or medal artwork separately, and you pay nothing until you approve the complete design for every piece in the order.
Ready to see your baseball trophies with your logo?
Free mockup within 24 hours. Minimum order 12. Standard turnaround about 2 weeks, faster available. You pay nothing until you approve the design.
Related pages
- Get a custom quote
- How it works
- Custom baseball medals
- Custom baseball trophies in bulk
- Team participation trophies
- Sculpted resin trophies
- Offseason baseball trophies: fall ball, holiday and hot stove awards
- Engraved Baseball Trophies with Team Logo: Laser-Engraved Plates, Etched Crystal and Name Personalization
Win Free Stuff
Enter below for a chance to win plus receive 10% off your first order.
🎉 You are in!
We will text you your 10% off code. Good luck!